Zim Cricket elections face court challenge

HARARE - An official within Zimbabwe Cricket (ZC) is seeking to have results of last year’s board elections nullified and the entire new leadership disbanded, citing violation of electoral regulations in the whole process.

Claudius Mukandiwa, vice chairman of the Harare Metropolitan Province Cricket Association, the country’s biggest cricket franchise is now legally challenging the overall outcome of the ZC elections after he and other board hopefuls were disqualified from the race.

Mukandiwa says the expulsion was unlawful and that the elections were “stolen”, claiming that there had been a clandestine attempt prior to the board elections to block certain candidates in order to influence the vote’s overall outcome.

But during the election, other candidates who had also been disqualified were later nicodemusly sneaked into the polls.

Such was the case with Bulawayo Metro chairman Vumindaba Moyo who was disqualified together with Mukandiwa but was later reinstituted on the day of the election and so did William Chaitezvi, a Harare resident who won the Mashonaland Central chairmanship post under controversial circumstances.

Chaitezvi sat on the Mashonaland West board at the time he sought election into the Mash Central board in clear violation of the provincial constitution section 20 (1) makes it an offence for one to seat on a provincial board they are not resident to.

The election saw Tavengwa Mukuhlani defeat interim chairman Wilson Manase, who was expected to be elected unopposed and secure his own term after taking over from the retiring Peter Chingoka in July 2014.The newly-elected ZC board proceeded to elect the chairman and his deputy.

Chris Venturas, who is part of the legal team representing Mukandiwa, says the disqualification of his client together with his colleagues had an impact on the overall outcome of the election.

“The whole election must be set aside because it was deeply flawed,” Venturas, who also represented the 15 “rebel” players after the famous walkout in 2004, told the Daily News.

Venturas added that ZC had also ignored its electoral constitutional requirement which necessitates the inclusion of legal and financial experts on the board. In his challenging papers, Mukandiwa claims he was initially disqualified for “lacking sports administration experience”, but the basis of his ineligibility was later changed and he was instead told his nomination papers had in fact gone missing.

Mukandiwa, is a former club player, who apart from previously working for ZC and founding Uprising Cricket Club, has also served as a provincial and area manager in Mashonaland West and Midlands in addition to acting as the national academy manager.

“I have no doubt that they pulled out my papers just to elbow me out of the race,” he said.

“What baffled me was that a senior ZC staffer called me indicating that my papers were missing two weeks after I submitted them. I took up the issue with her boss who told me his subordinate had broken protocol for she wasn’t supposed to be the one communicating with us on such issues. My worst fears were confirmed on the day of the election when I was told I’d been disqualified.”

He further claims there had been manoeuvres to exclude from the board individuals with an “impeccable cricket background” like him.

Another electoral irregularity cited by Mukandiwa is the questionable eligibility of provincial association board heads who automatically take sits on the ZC board and have a huge amount of influence on how the game is run in the country.

Mukandiwa claims all is not well in Zimbabwe cricket following August’s elections, saying the anxiety reflected in the national team’s recent results.

“Look what is happening now, losing to Afghanistan in back to back series’… the players are reacting to what’s happening off the field. I’m afraid Zim cricket is on a downward spiral again.”

Comments (4)

We just don't have quality players to take on the world. Mukandiwa might have a case, but to link poor results, by our boys to local elections is ill advised. Our boys have been losing before,during and after elections. Treat players on merit, and we black people should stop being racist, A zimbabwean is a zimbabwean wether his colour is green, or purple is immaterial. The blame sqaurely lies with us, day in day out counter production activities and we expect is success.

X-MAN IV - 10 January 2016

Dave Whatmore should now be shown the exit. The guy has failed our cricket period.

gurinhwa - 11 January 2016

Elections have always been doctored at Zimbabwe cricket. The leadership will always be in the cluthes of PC and OB, who ever the deem to be a threat to the influence will be elbowed out. With you Claudius on this one.

Brie - 12 January 2016

If government really has the interests of the people and cricket at heart, they would dissolve ZC and allow more qualified and cricket loving personnel to run the sport...even though they mave to bite on their back teeth and allow a few whites to do this. There is no doubt the current administrators are incompetent and short sighted, filling their own pockets first and there is a degree of racism.

Brian - 14 January 2016

Post a comment

Readers are kindly requested to refrain from using abusive, vulgar, racist, tribalistic, sexist, discriminatory and hurtful language when posting their comments on the Daily News website.
Those who transgress this civilised etiquette will be barred from contributing to our online discussions.
- Editor

Your email address will not be shared.
Enter the three characters from the image on the right. This helps prevent automated 'bots' from submitting spam to the site. This field is NOT case-sensitive. If the characters are a bit hard to see, try refreshing the code by clicking the image.