Govt bars Zimsec school ratings

HARARE - Government has barred the Zimbabwe Schools Examination Council (Zimsec) from compiling the top 100 schools in this year’s Grade Seven examinations, preferring it to be done by the minister of Primary and Secondary Education.

Over the years, Zimsec  has been ranking schools’ pass rates on a top 100 table — a development that attracted mixed reactions from parents, school authorities  and other stakeholders over the criteria used by the national  examinations body to rank the schools.

While schools that dominated the rankings hailed Zimsec, those that failed to make it criticised the criteria for failing to consider variables such as inter-alia the school type, and enrolment in terms of teacher-pupil ratio.

Primary and Secondary Education minister Lazarus Dokora told the Daily News yesterday that owing to groans from several education stakeholders, his ministry had decided to take over the compilation of that list.

“Our team is busy working on modalities to ensure that we come with more inclusive criteria and until the team is finished there will not be any ranking of schools in terms of their academic performances,” Dokora said without giving time-frames by which the exercise is expected to be completed.

“How do you explain for example, a situation where at a school two candidates sit for an examination and they pass then the institution is ranked the best in the country on that basis?

“We need to look at that anomaly with a view to correcting it.”

Dokora’s views are also reflected in some of the feedback that the Daily News which has been reporting on the top 100 over the years received, each time the list was published.

“There should be a minimum number of students per school to allow it to be ranked otherwise we can’t compare a school with only eight candidates with the one with 50, this is a shame comparison,” said a teacher from a Mashonaland Central school who only identified himself as Nhau when the 2014 top 100 for Grade Seven examinations was published.

“You are giving credit to wrong people.

“If all seven candidates at Mutare blah blah School had four units and seven best performers from the 98 Mahatshula had four units, then how on earth can
Mutare blah blah justify their number one!?”

Another reader who identified himself as Mahembe said, “Let’s revisit the whole education system and give constructive criticism.

“Could you also include the most improved and also consider rural schools on their own.”

Forty primary schools, led by Mutare Probation Primary, attained an incredible 100 percent pass rate in the November 2014 Zimsec examinations.

According to Zimsec statistics, the rest of the schools that  completed the top 100 table scored a percentage pass rate of over 94 percent, culminating in an improved Grade Seven national pass rate from the 32,2 percent recorded in 2013.

In 2013, only 22 schools attained 100 percent pass rate as compared to 40 that attained that feat last year while that of 2012 was 31,5 percent.

As if to justify Dokora’s ban, the majority of the top-ranked learning institutions were private schools.

Mutare Probation situated in Ward 10 in Mutare Central for example has an enrolment of only 39 boys and these are taught by three teachers.

Other schools which recorded a 100 percent pass rate were Waterfalls Primary, Redcliff Primary, Old Windsor Primary, Hippo Valley Estates Primary School, Citrus Primary School, Saiss Junior School, Bata Committee Primary, Rutengeni Primary, Mvurachena Primary, Mutarazi Junior School and Russell Primary.

Comments (2)

We are so used to sweeping things under the carpert to protect each other. Zimsec rankings did not and never attempted to explain the pass rates. Just said, at School A, 140 students sat for the exams. All passed so they attained a 100%. At school B, 15 sat, 5 passed. Pass rate was 33%. Now it will be up to the school to explain their low pass rates when stacked up against those that passed. We are a rural school and our circumstance explains our pass rate. If no other rural school passed, then we know we have a problem that requires government's intervention. If a school in similar situation passed then we ask, what is the other school doing differently. Then we study its model and see if there are any lessons to be learnt etc etc. Dont shoot the messenger. ZIMSEC rankings were just a mirror showing us how particular schools were faring. And the messenger will not be going back to his master. Why? Cause we shot him. We hate bearers of bad news.

Wiriranayi - 11 December 2015

The Minister is right. How do you account for the difference between the units that are demanded by other schools when other schools just take any.

chirasha chikandamina - 11 December 2015

Post a comment

Readers are kindly requested to refrain from using abusive, vulgar, racist, tribalistic, sexist, discriminatory and hurtful language when posting their comments on the Daily News website.
Those who transgress this civilised etiquette will be barred from contributing to our online discussions.
- Editor

Your email address will not be shared.