'Zanu PF vitriol betrays its panic'

HARARE - President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu PF appears to be in panic mode as liberation struggle stalwarts prepare to mount a landmark legal challenge in the High Court against the tearing of the party’s rule book.

Analysts told the Daily News yesterday that the escalating and vitriolic attacks on former Presidential Affairs minister Didymus Mutasa by party bigwigs, as well as the fact that lickspittle State media had gone into overdrive in a bid to discredit him, betrayed the nervousness around the matter within the leadership of the party.

These sentiments came as State newspapers reported that the mooted challenge was allegedly a futile exercise because it did not have a sound legal standing, amid further claims that former vice president Joice Mujuru’s supporters had allegedly disassociated themselves from the action.

“The vicious attacks (on Mutasa) are par for the course, and the modus operandi of these particular cadres (the attackers). There is not much subtlety to it,” said Piers Pigou, Southern African director of the International Crisis Group.

“And yes, this is about the court of public opinion more than anything else. The divisions beyond the public leadership spats have not been resolved, and the aftershock of the purges are likely to reverberate for some time.

“Some may interpret this as panic by the new incumbents. I also sense that it may reflect their failure to date to maintain the momentum of their purging and reconfiguration of Zanu PF’s hierarchy,” Pigou added.

He said all this raised “profound questions” about Zanu PF’s commitment to the rule of law, and their own rulebook.

“Where is the constitution and exactly what are these processes and amendments? I think Mutasa may have a case to make, but I really don’t think Zimbabwe’s courts are in a position to provide a remedy.

“It would be an important test of their independence and integrity,” Pigou said.

Macdonald Lewanika, executive director of the Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition, said part of the reason why Zanu PF was panicking was that the challenge was coming from one of their own, who knew all the shenanigans within the movement.

“This is different from a fight brought by outsiders with no inside knowledge. So from a potency perspective, the fact that Mutasa really knows his enemies is one that makes Zanu PF more vulnerable than fights that others have staged and taken to Zanu PF’s door.

“If Zanu PF want to argue the case, let them do so in court and not try to question Mutasa’s issues in the court of public opinion in convoluted fashion, especially if they have nothing to fear.

“On the other hand, knowing how the courts are in Zimbabwe, Zanu PF might be trying to set the tone for an eventual outcome that they know, which is unfortunate for us as a country as it creates the impression that indeed the courts get their brief from those in political power rather than their own independent legal adjudication,” Lewanika said.

Alex Magaisa, a law lecturer at the University of Kent in the UK, said war veterans and Zanu PF cadres were trying to solve “an intensely political matter” using the courts.

He predicted that this would not yield any positive results.

He said there was a great likelihood that the case would be dismissed one way or the other and that the courts would advice Mutasa to seek a political solution.

“His problem is that apart from himself and former (Zanu PF spokesperson Rugare) Gumbo, no one else seems to have come forward to back his cause and that is a huge weakness in the court of politics.

“This is a political issue that requires a political solution and I do not think the courts of law will be of any assistance. Even if the court awards a decision, who will enforce it?

“The possibility that Zanu PF can hold another congress is as remote as the possibility of a nonagenarian becoming a teenager again,” Magaisa said.

Another analyst, Rejoice Ngwenya, concurred with Magaisa, adding that the party controlled all institutions of governance, including the judiciary.

“The Herald wants to appeal to the wider pro-Zanu PF audience ... anyhow, the only way Mutasa can bust the ring is through evidence that the (contested) votes of no confidence produced illegitimate provincial structures that legitimised constitutional reform.

“In principle, a Mutasa expose that has no hard facts and witnesses has no legal traction,” Ngwenya said.

Contacted for comment, Mutasa and his lawyer Gula Ndebele said they were not at liberty to discuss the matter as it was for the courts to decide.


Comments (12)

Dzasukwa is 2 hours fro Harare airport. Around 1430 hours he will be landing. Watch the step and give us before leaving the country and now. Addis Ababa next stop, humambo ... Having beaten KK he will be ready to rest!?

Guramatunhu Dzawira - 22 January 2015

I do not believe there is one person in ZPF that has the guts or the courage to stand up for what is right.

TruthBTold - 22 January 2015

Ngozi ya Christpowers Maisiri yabata Mutasa.

Fox Makwiravana - 22 January 2015

FOR SALE HP TONER CARTRIDGES 05A,10A,11A,12A,13A,15A,24A,35A,36A42A,49A,53A,55A,61A,64A,70A,78A,80A,83A,85A,90A,96A,125A,131A,135A,AND MANYMORE 0772 678 311

CARTRIDGE GALLERY - 22 January 2015

FOR SALE HP TONER CARTRIDGES 05A,10A,11A,12A,13A,15A,24A,35A,36A42A,49A,53A,55A,61A,64A,70A,78A,80A,83A,85A,90A,96A,125A,131A,135A,AND MANYMORE 0772 678 311

CARTRIDGE GALLERY - 22 January 2015

Zanu-PF chaos. Hanzi naChinotimba I will clean Mbare...He should clean his behind first. Tsxva..(tsamwa)

selele - 22 January 2015

Whatever the situation every one has a right to aproach the courts let the judicial decide not the press.

David Panganai - 22 January 2015

under zanu pf government there is no law to talk about. These zanu pf rejects are taking a wrong route. Its like they dont know how their party works. They must challange zanu pf style. As long mugabe is alive no court will rule in their favour. They know where zanu pf HQ is and there must go there to sort their internal "wars".

X-man IV - 22 January 2015


mahippos - 22 January 2015

Vozotaura nhasi no kuti adzoka

Aiwa Kweteh - 22 January 2015

Useless leader. I am failing to see what this oldman is doing in the office. Iko kuri kuda kufira pachigaro here. Presidence is not Kingship varume. The country is ever struggling. Haiwa tanzwa varume chiiko kuomesa mwoyo

Mapfumo - 23 January 2015

If there is any legal substance in Mutasa's story - the court will keep postponing the case until he - Mutasa is dead. This Zanu PF yeropa.

clement moyo - 23 January 2015

Post a comment

Readers are kindly requested to refrain from using abusive, vulgar, racist, tribalistic, sexist, discriminatory and hurtful language when posting their comments on the Daily News website.
Those who transgress this civilised etiquette will be barred from contributing to our online discussions.
- Editor

Your email address will not be shared.