Dudu Manhenga's bail application thrown out

HARARE - Harare magistrate Blessing Murwisi yesterday dismissed convicted jazz musician Dudu Manhenga’s bail application pending appeal.

Manhenga was jailed for an effective one-and-half-years over a culpable homicide charge.

Magistrate Murwisi dismissed her application on the basis there were no prospects of success of the appeal against her sentence.

In her bail application, made through her legal representative, Manhenga argued that she was able to stand trial  three years after committing the offence, and that she was able to make herself available for sentence after her conviction.

Her lawyer further submitted that she was a proper candidate for bail, saying she was of fixed abode and not a flight risk at all.

However, the court dismissed her application saying the offences committed by the jazz artiste were very serious and that there was a likelihood Manhenga could abscond if granted bail.

The State, led by Barbra Ndoro, had no opposition to the application but magistrate Murwisi noted that the State had encouraged the court to give a custodial sentence before she made her final ruling last Friday.
In her notice of application against the sentence, Manhenga had argued that the court had failed to make a factual inquiry to establish the degree of negligence before the ruling.

The court however said there was no need to make such inquiry because Manhenga had a defence lawyer.

Murwisi said the sentence was most appropriate because Manhenga demonstrated gross negligence.

Charges against the songstress, who is a trainee pastor, arose after she hit the now deceased, Graham Martin in Mabelreign, Harare in March 2010.

She faces a further three months in prison for another charge of driving using a learner’s licence without supervision, which has an option for a $300 fine.

In passing sentence, Murwisi had considered that Manhenga was a first time offender and mother of four children but said she exuded gross negligence.

She said the jazz songstress had shown gross negligence by turning right in front of oncoming traffic thus putting the life of an innocent road user at risk.

Manhenga’s lawyer had pleaded for a non-custodial sentence and said the accident was a result of contributory negligence.

He said the now deceased Martin contributed to his death by riding a motor bike without a helmet.

Comments (6)

It seems to me this was negligence indeed. There are so many of these unlicensed incompetent drivers whom we dodge countless times. My sympathy lies with the Martin family

observer - 15 October 2013

many of these unlicensed drivers are kombi drivers who are protected by grossly corrupt police who let them carry excess passangers everyday and let them pass roadblcks without valid driver licences by recieving fixed bribes of $10 per day per kombi. rimwe zuva gava richadambura musungo.

chacks - 16 October 2013

many of these unlicensed drivers are kombi drivers who are protected by grossly corrupt police who let them carry excess passangers everyday and let them pass roadblcks without valid driver licences by recieving fixed bribes of $10 per day per kombi. rimwe zuva gava richadambura musungo.

chacks - 16 October 2013

Please Dhuhdu i don't know why you are wasting your money on baseless legal arguments you kiled an innocent person, agreed you were driving without a liscenced driver as per the law i think you deserve this sentence it is actually a lesser sentence this should have been 4 years in prison. I ALSO WANT TO URGE THE POLICE TRAFFIC SENIORS WE ARE TIRED OF DODGING THESE UNLISCENCED DRIVERS ESPECIALLY THOSE DRIVING AUTOMATIC CARS WHICH HAVE FLOODED ZIMBABWE SIMPLE RULES OF THE HIGHWAY CODE ARE NOT EVEN FOLLOWED. One good example when one is making a turn in an inner lane , that car eventually after making a turn you see the car comming to the outer lane simple road regulations so please make sure you mount road blocks and check these drivers, I am astonished i realised there are actually more police officers who are driving thes automatic cars without even a provisional liscence and i have noticed some even drive these cars just after importing them for 1-2 yrs without even valid number plates act now

Automatic - 16 October 2013

mmm dhudhu u r a gd person m sorry for u nwhere m also sory for the Martin family its a mishap

sam - 16 October 2013

Its unfortunate. Life is the greatest gift of all. Once lost it can never be recovered. These words might assist you Dhudhu in whatever appeal you might intend to make. However you are a good girl we love you so much. Am sorry for the loss to Martin's family.

sekai - 16 October 2013

Post a comment

Readers are kindly requested to refrain from using abusive, vulgar, racist, tribalistic, sexist, discriminatory and hurtful language when posting their comments on the Daily News website.
Those who transgress this civilised etiquette will be barred from contributing to our online discussions.
- Editor

Your email address will not be shared.